CTR K

Planetary Gears — validation & limitations

What this calculator checks and the method behind each result, the independent reference cases its engine is tested against, and what it does not check. Use it to decide how far you can rely on a result.

Open the Planetary Gears

What it calculates

Standard / method: ISO 6336-based

ISO 6336-based flank (ISO 6336-2) and tooth-root (ISO 6336-3 Method B) rating of the sun, planet and ring on the shared /gears engine, each member with its own load cycles; planet root fully reversed · K_γ load sharing from IEC 61400-4:2012 by planet count unless measured · K_Hα / K_Fα by ISO 6336-1 Method B and K_Hβ by Method C (no shaft deflection) · kinematics from the Willis equation

Engineering estimate — this tool uses an accepted simplified model rather than one citable governing standard. Use it for preliminary sizing and verify the final design against manufacturer data or a qualified engineer.

  • Gear ratio for 3K-I (ring fixed) and 3K-II (sun fixed), plus a Wolfrom option that is an explicitly badged single-stage STAND-IN, not a Wolfrom rating
  • Read-only kinematic table covering three input/output/fixed arrangements, including the carrier-fixed reversal
  • Flank (ISO 6336-2) and tooth-root (ISO 6336-3 Method B) safety of the sun, the planet (both flanks) and the ring, on the shared /gears engine
  • Load cycles per member from the carrier-relative speeds: sun one per planet per revolution, planet one per flank, ring one per planet per revolution
  • Real contact path with undercut and form circles; tip-to-fillet interference of the internal mesh, rated on the ring's shaper cutter when entered
  • Sun profile shift with the planet shift solved for coaxial centre distances
  • Planet load sharing K_γ from IEC 61400-4:2012 for 3–7 planets, or your measured value
  • Separate ring material and rim thickness; K_A, accuracy grade, life, roughness and oil as inputs, each default listed
  • Inverse job: the input power at which every member reaches S_H 1.2 and S_F 1.4
  • Planet bearing load (pin force plus centrifugal force) for the bearing selection
  • All three assembly conditions carried into the headline verdict: the mesh condition and actual planet interference as hard failures, equal spacing and tip clearance as warnings
  • Mesh efficiency from the tooth friction coefficient, swept over input power, with a cooling-threshold rule of thumb

Standards this tool applies

  • ISO 6336 — ISO 6336-2 flank and ISO 6336-3 Method B root safety of the sun, planet and ring on the cylindrical-gear engine, each member with its own load cycles, with IEC 61400-4 load sharing. SCOPE: a screening calculation, not a full ISO 6336 rating — K_Hβ follows the AGMA form (not ISO 6336-1 Method B; K_Hα / K_Fα are Method B); K_A, the accuracy grade, the life, the flank roughness and the oil are inputs, and S_H is taken against σ_H,lim × Z_NT·Z_X·Z_L·Z_V·Z_R. Verify a marginal design against a full rating.

Validation evidence — independent reference cases (1)

Each case runs the tool's engine on a worked example whose values come from a published source or a hand derivation from the cited equations, and an automated regression test asserts the engine against those values within the stated tolerance. "Conservative" means the engine is known to sit on the safe side of the reference and the test asserts that side. Sources are cited; their text is not reproduced.

  • Kinematic ratio and carrier-output efficiency

    Conservative

    Source: Willis equation (Mueller, Epicyclic Drive Trains, 1982, ch. 2; Shigley ch. 13); Mueller efficiency of a simple planetary train; Niemann/Winter Maschinenelemente Bd. II mesh-loss estimate

    Inputs: zs 20, zp 30, zr 80, 3 planets, m 2, 1500 rpm, 10 kW, 3K-I, mu 0.04

    QuantityReference valueEngineTolerance
    ratio / output speed5.000 / 300 rpm—1e-12 relative
    efficiency98.955 % (Niemann internal-mesh sign)98.7063 %1e-6 vs hand; engine <= 98.955 %
    output torque314.21 N·m—1e-6 relative

    Conservative simplification: The engine adds the mesh-loss term for the internal ring-planet mesh instead of subtracting it, so efficiency reads about 0.25 points below the Niemann internal-mesh value.

    tests/golden/REF-planetary-efficiency.golden.test.ts

Limitations

Conservative simplifications

Not checked by this tool

  • Ring rim bending and mounting — The ring and planet roots carry Y_B for the entered rims (ringRimMm, planetRimMm; omitted ⇒ solid, CHECK where a thinner valid rim would fail); ring rim bending and its mounting need FE
  • Work-hardening factor Z_W in the printed S_H — S_H takes Z_W 1.0; a through-hardened ring under hardened planets gets the ISO 6336-2 estimate in the verdict and the max power
  • Planet bearing life — The tool gives the bearing load (pin force + centrifugal); size the bearing for it with /bearings
  • Carrier deflection and the real load sharing between planets — Load sharing uses the IEC 61400-4 K_γ default unless a measured value is entered; confirm with measured or FE data
  • Scuffing, micropitting, low-speed wear and the gearbox thermal rating — Scuffing, micropitting and wear are not rated (ISO/TS 6336-20/21/22; wear decides stages below ~0.5 m/s); efficiency is mesh-only — check the heat balance (bearing, seal, churning losses) with the gearbox maker
  • Measured pitch deviation, ring profile shift and planet-pin detail — K_Hα / K_Fα use the grade's pitch tolerance; the ring is cut unshifted (the sun shift is entered, the planet's follows); the pin check is bending only (no shear / fatigue / fit) — check the pin with your carrier design
  • Wolfrom (two-ring) drives — The Wolfrom option is a single-stage stand-in sized on the sun torque (a real Wolfrom ring carries ~i × the input torque) — it is capped at CHECK; rate a real Wolfrom with its own two-ring model

Results are engineering calculations for qualified users — see the disclaimer. Other tools: all validation pages · standards reference · symbols glossary.