Cylindrical Gears — validation & limitations
What this calculator checks and the method behind each result, the independent reference cases its engine is tested against, and what it does not check. Use it to decide how far you can rely on a result.
Open the Cylindrical GearsWhat it calculates
Standard / method: ISO 6336
ISO 6336-1/-2/-3:2006-based load factors, contact stress and root bending stress by ISO 6336-3 Method B (form factor YF and stress-correction factor YS from the root-fillet geometry at the outer point of single-pair contact — see FAQ for the full applied/simplified breakdown) · DIN 3990-1 Method C (KV; DIN 3962 K1 values) · AGMA 2001-D04 / Shigley §14-11 (KHβ / Km) · DIN 3960 / ISO 21771 (profile shift, involute geometry)
- ISO 6336-3 Method B tooth-root bending stress — form factor YF and stress-correction factor YS from the root-fillet geometry at the outer point of single-pair contact, helix factor Yβ, size factor YX and the rim-thickness factor YB from an optional rim-thickness input — enter it for a thin-rim or web gear and the backup-ratio penalty is applied
- ISO 6336 Hertzian contact stress with zone factor ZH, elasticity factor ZE, contact-ratio factor Zε and helix factor Zβ, including single-pair tooth-contact factors ZB/ZD for spur and partial-overlap helical gears; the permissible flank stress carries the size factor ZX and the lubricant, velocity and roughness factors ZL·ZV·ZR from your oil viscosity and flank roughness
- DIN 3990-1 Method C dynamic load factor KV across quality grades Q6–Q12 (DIN 3962 / DIN 3990 Method C K1 values; the mapping to ISO 1328 grades is not verified), face-load distribution factor KHβ by ISO 6336-1 Method C (the grade's helix tolerance, crowning / end relief and assembly adjustment selectable, an overhung pinion's shaft slope when entered — never below the AGMA 2001-D04 / Shigley Eq. 14-30 enclosed-unit estimate), and bending face-load factor KFβ = KHβ^NF per ISO 6336-1
- Application factor KA as a selectable input (ISO 6336-1 Annex B / DIN 3990-1 guide table) and finite-life rating via the ISO 6336 life factors Y_NT (bending) and Z_NT (contact) — enter a required number of load cycles, or leave it for the conservative continuous-duty (endurance) design
- Profile shift analysis to ISO 6336 / DIN 3960: operating centre distance, operating pressure angle and transverse contact ratio εα computed from the involute function
- Sensitivity (tornado) analysis — contact safety factor SH vs ±20% variation in module, face width, power and pinion tooth count
Standards this tool applies
- ISO 6336 — ISO 6336 rating of spur & helical gear pairs — σH, σF, SH, SF, with the ISO 6336-2/-3 stress and life factors. Two of the Part 1 load factors are NOT ISO 6336: K_Hβ follows the AGMA/Shigley commercial-enclosed-unit form (an ISO 6336-1 Method B/C value can be supplied to override it), and K_Hα / K_Fα follow the §8.3.4 Method B expression with both upper limits (or an entered Method A value).
Related standards — reference only, not implemented
- AGMA 2101reference only — ISO 6336 contact and bending stress for spur & helical gear pairs, with a Shigley-form (AGMA-style) face-load distribution factor Km as K_Hβ. No AGMA 2101 rating is computed.
Validation evidence — independent reference cases (2)
Each case runs the tool's engine on a worked example whose values come from a published source or a hand derivation from the cited equations, and an automated regression test asserts the engine against those values within the stated tolerance. "Conservative" means the engine is known to sit on the safe side of the reference and the test asserts that side. Sources are cited; their text is not reproduced.
Flank (pitting) safety factor SH through the ISO 6336-2 Method B chain
ConservativeSource: ISO 6336-1/-2:2006 Method B (σH0, ZH, ZE, Zε, ZB/ZD, ZL, ZV, ZR) with DIN 3990-1:1987 Method C dynamic factor KV and KHα guide value 1.1
Inputs: spur mn 4, z1 20, z2 50, b 40 mm, x 0, 30 kW at 1450 rpm, grade 7, KA 1.0, KHβ 1.20, σHlim 1500 MPa, Rz 4 µm, ISO VG 100, K_Hα 1.1 entered (the guide value; the tool computes Method B when it is left out)
Quantity Reference value Engine Tolerance Dynamic factor KV 1.161515 1.2873 one-sided (engine >= reference) — the grade read coarser Flank stress σH,B (pinion) 816.522 MPa 859.58 MPa one-sided (engine >= reference) Permissible stress σHG 1396.2367 MPa — 2e-4 relative Flank safety factor SH (pinion governs) 1.709981 1.6243 one-sided (engine <= reference) Conservative simplification: For the dynamic factor the tool reads the entered grade 7 1.5 grades coarser (K1 29.07 for the DIN 3990 grade-7 15.3), so the K_V of a drawing that states an ISO grade is never under-read; on this DIN-grade reference case that puts the engine on the safe side.
tests/golden/REF-gears-contact-pitting.golden.test.ts
Tooth-root bending safety factors SF1 / SF2 vs ISO 6336-3 Method B
ConservativeSource: ISO 6336-3:2006 Method B (σF = σF0·KA·KV·KFβ·KFα, YF/YS at outer single-pair contact) with ISO 6336-1:2006 load factors
Inputs: spur mn 4, z1 20, z2 50, b 40 mm, x 0, 30 kW at 1450 rpm, grade 7, KA 1.0, KHβ 1.20, σFlim 500 MPa, K_Fα 1.1 entered (the guide value; the tool computes Method B when it is left out)
Quantity Reference value Engine Tolerance SF1 (pinion) 7.693818 (tool fillet 0.38·mn); 6.719842 (0.20·mn) 6.0628 one-sided (engine <= reference) to both — the 0.20·mn fillet and the grade read coarser for K_V SF2 (wheel) 8.152738 (tool fillet 0.38·mn); 7.001262 (0.20·mn) 6.3167 one-sided (engine <= reference) to both KFβ 1.153646 — 1e-6 relative Pinion YF·YS (Method B, 0.20·mn) 3.270440 — 1e-5 relative Conservative simplification: The engine is ISO 6336-3 Method B with the smallest standard hob fillet (0.20·mn) assumed, because the tool radius is not an input; on this case that reads about 13 % below the value for the common 0.38·mn hob. Also, for the dynamic factor the tool reads the entered grade 7 1.5 grades coarser (K1 29.07 for the DIN 3990 grade-7 15.3), so the K_V of a drawing that states an ISO grade is never under-read; on this DIN-grade reference case that puts the engine on the safe side.
tests/golden/REF-gears-root-bending.golden.test.ts
Limitations
Conservative simplifications
- Flank (pitting) safety factor SH through the ISO 6336-2 Method B chain — For the dynamic factor the tool reads the entered grade 7 1.5 grades coarser (K1 29.07 for the DIN 3990 grade-7 15.3), so the K_V of a drawing that states an ISO grade is never under-read; on this DIN-grade reference case that puts the engine on the safe side.
- Tooth-root bending safety factors SF1 / SF2 vs ISO 6336-3 Method B — The engine is ISO 6336-3 Method B with the smallest standard hob fillet (0.20·mn) assumed, because the tool radius is not an input; on this case that reads about 13 % below the value for the common 0.38·mn hob. Also, for the dynamic factor the tool reads the entered grade 7 1.5 grades coarser (K1 29.07 for the DIN 3990 grade-7 15.3), so the K_V of a drawing that states an ISO grade is never under-read; on this DIN-grade reference case that puts the engine on the safe side.
Not checked by this tool
- Double-helical gears, speed increasers and high-speed (turbo) gears — One helix as a single-helical pair (doubleHelical: section on 2·b); smaller gear as z1, increasers too. Turbo: grades finer than 6 not covered, K_V valid to v·z1/100 = 10 m/s (above it CHECK); ask the maker
- Scuffing (ISO/TS 6336-20/21), micropitting (ISO/TS 6336-22) and flank fracture (ISO/TS 6336-4) — Only a scuffing screening indicator is shown; the others are not rated — check high-speed or case-hardened, highly loaded flanks with the gear maker
- Static / peak-torque tooth strength (ISO 6336 static rating) — Only the endurance (fatigue) rating is computed; check start-up, stall and shock peak torque against the static root and flank strength (ISO 6336-2/-3 with the static life factors ZNT / YNT)
- Tip thickness margin above the guidelines, and tip shortening — A pointed tip is refused; CHECK below 0.2 x module, and below 0.4 x module on a surface-hardened tip (confirm the case depth there); a shortened tip is not modelled — confirm with the gear maker
- Measured pitch deviation for K_Hα / K_Fα — Method B takes the grade's single-pitch tolerance as the base-pitch deviation; enter a Method A value (K_Hα override) when measured deviations are known
- Load spectrum / duty cycle (Miner damage sum) — One load case is rated at the entered power and speed; for a varying duty, rate each level and combine the damage with Miner's rule, or rate the equivalent load with the gear maker
- Gear body, shafts and bearings: hub, web, bore / keyway, and the shafts and bearings for the mesh forces — Check the shaft-hub connection with /keys or /pressfit, the web on the gear drawing, and size the shafts and bearings with /shaft and /bearings
- Work-hardening factor Z_W in S_H, and the gearbox thermal rating — S_H takes Z_W 1.0; the softer through-hardened member on a hardened mate gets the ISO 6336-2 estimate as CHECK / FAIL beside it; the heat balance needs the gearbox maker's rating
Results are engineering calculations for qualified users — see the disclaimer. Other tools: all validation pages · standards reference · symbols glossary.